Visit New Jersey: Papa's Tomato Pies

When in New Jersey, Tomato Pies are a must.  Tomato Pies are basically a crust covered with cheese then tomatoes (versus tomatoes then cheese).  

We decided to pick up a Tomato Pie from Papa's Tomatoes Pies, which is claimed to be the oldest pizzeria in the US, as well as a Mustard Pie.

Tomato Pie

Mustard Pie

The Tomato Pie was delicious, but the Mustard Pie was the unanimous favorite.  Mustard is put into the dough before baking, giving it a nice tang and a little bit of bite.  I really enjoyed it.

Definitely give the Mustard Pie a try if you find yourself at Papa's!

Papa's Tomato Pies
19 Main St, 

Robbinsville Twp NJ 08691

Read More

Visit New Jersey: De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies

While in New Jersey, we knew we had to try a Tomato Pie, so we headed to De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies.

Unlike a traditional pizza in which a crust is topped with tomatoes then cheese, a Tomato Pie is basically a crust topped with cheese then tomatoes.

We got three Tomato Pies - a classic, plus two others with additional toppings.

Classic

Pepperoni + Sausage

Garlic + Mushroom + Onions

The Tomato Pies were amazing!  The crust was thin and crispy, and the toppings were just delish.

Our family nearly demolished all three small pies!

Everything is made to order, so you may have a little bit of a wait for your pies, especially if it's very busy (in fact, it was consistently busy the entire time we were at De Lorenzo's), but the pies are so worth the wait.

You must try a Tomato Pie at De Lorenzo's when in New Jersey!

De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies
2350 NJ-33

Robbinsville, NJ 08691
(609) 341-8480

Read More