October 25, 2021

Visit New Jersey: Papa's Tomato Pies

When in New Jersey, Tomato Pies are a must.  Tomato Pies are basically a crust covered with cheese then tomatoes (versus tomatoes then cheese).  

We decided to pick up a Tomato Pie from Papa's Tomatoes Pies, which is claimed to be the oldest pizzeria in the US, as well as a Mustard Pie.

Tomato Pie

Mustard Pie

The Tomato Pie was delicious, but the Mustard Pie was the unanimous favorite.  Mustard is put into the dough before baking, giving it a nice tang and a little bit of bite.  I really enjoyed it.

Definitely give the Mustard Pie a try if you find yourself at Papa's!

Papa's Tomato Pies
19 Main St, 
Robbinsville Twp NJ 08691

No comments:

Post a Comment